Vous êtes ici
Lunch seminar with Philippe Mongin
Organised by the Governance and Regulation Chair
SPEAKER :
"Qu'est-ce qu'un récit analytique* ?"
The recently born expression “analytic narratives” refers to studies that have appeared at the boundaries of history, political science and economics. These studies purport to explain spe- cific historical events by combining the usual narrative way of historians with the analytic tools that economists and political scientists find in rational choice theory. Game theory is promin- ent among these tools. The paper explains what analytic narratives are by sampling from the eponymous book Analytic Narratives by Bates, Greif, Levi, Rosenthal and Weingast and cov- ering one outside study by Mongin (2008). It first evaluates the explanatory performance of the new genre, using some philosophy of historical explanation, and then checks its discursive consistency, using some narratology. The paper concludes that analytic narratives can usefully complement standard narratives in historical explanation, provided they specialize in the gaps that these narratives reveal, and that they are discursively consistent, despite the tension that combining a formal model with a narration creates. Two expository modes, called alternation and local supplementation, emerge from the discussion as the most appropriate ones to resolve this tension.
* La présentation mettra en relation la recherche historique avec les modèles de l'action venus des théories mathématiques du choix rationnel, notamment de la théorie des jeux.
Veuillez noter que le déjeuner sera fourni lors de l'inscription seulement.